On our most recent visit to Mexico I had a reaction to the Simple Wipes that I brought with me so I had to look for an alternative and since I had my eye on the Garnier Skin Naturals Makeup Remover for a while, decided to purchase it since it was also available over there.
The Garnier Skin Naturals Makeup Remover, also known as Clean Detox, is a 2 in 1 cleanser that can be used on the eyes and face. As it is a bi-phase product you need to shake it prior to use, but doesn't need extreme shaking to mix the 2 phases unlike the Nivea Eye Makeup Remover.
This makeup remover claims to remove even waterproof makeup while being soothing and suitable for even sensitive skin since it contains rose water, pro vitamin B5, has no alcohol, no perfume and you don't need to rub your skin with the product in order for it to work.
I've used this cleanser/makeup remover for a while and I quite like it, as it is gentle and effective, easy to use, affordable and has an almost imperceptible scent. It does indeed remove waterproof makuep so I would recommend it if you are looking for a new makeup remover to try.